The fish sandwich is one of Bermuda’s most common snacks. The basic recipe is found islandwide: seasoned fish fillets, coated in flour or batter and fried, with tartar sauce, between two slices of bread. What sets it apart is the bread: the most traditional is raisin bread, slightly sweet, toasted or not. You can also ask for whole-wheat bread.
The fish is usually wahoo, snapper or grouper, all white-fleshed. Locals look for the contrast between the sweet bread, the salty crunchy fish and the sauce.
Ordering the sandwich “with the works” means fully loaded: lettuce, tomato, grilled onion, cheese, hot sauce and coleslaw, the creamy cabbage salad. Each place has its own take on the seasoning, the tartar sauce and the batter, and the contest for the island’s best fish sandwich is a frequent topic among residents.
There’s no record of when raisin bread became the standard. The sandwich appears everywhere, from simple kiosks and snack bars to more formal restaurants, at lunch or as a quick meal.